Thomas Frank grows increasingly concerned over Tottenham Hotspur star Brennan Johnson’s inconsistency
Tottenham Hotspur continue to grow as a club under Thomas Frank, who has set up his plans on precision, energy and relentless attacking transitions. The players are beginning to gel on the field, but amidst all these, there are still some problems in the squad that are troubling Frank.
We will talk about one such problem, and that is regarding the inconsistency of winger Brenan Johnson. The 24-year-old earned accolades during his time at Nottingham Forest and arrived at Tottenham under Ange. However, he has not found the same consistency as was expected from the Spurs jersey. It is definitely a sign of worry for Frank, who is trying to rebuild consistency in all departments for the club.
Frank’s faith meets reality
According to a report from Grame Bailey of TBR Football, Thomas Frank has begun to express concern over Brennan Johnson’s inconsistency despite recognising the player’s clear talent. The 24-year-old attracted Spurs’ attention with his pace to stretch defences and also be at the right place at the right time. However, it has not been smooth sailing for the Welsh International at Tottenham Hotspur Stadium.
Frank, however, believes Johnson has the quality to become a key part of his Tottenham side, but the inconsistency in his performances raises doubts about his reliability. The Wales international makes smart runs and displays his predatory instincts inside the box, but he delivers uneven output too often to earn Frank’s full trust.
Tottenham’s search for another wide player adds more pressure on Johnson’s place in the squad. As Graeme Bailey reported, the Welshman stays determined to convince Frank that he deserves a spot in his plans, but stronger competition keeps building around him. The manager values Johnson’s effort and attacking awareness, yet he expects greater consistency from his forwards to keep Tottenham’s momentum alive.
“Brennan Johnson is determined that he has a future at Spurs and can convince Thomas Frank that he can be a key player for him. We understand Frank likes Johnson and believes he is capable of playing at a high level, but the consistency factor is a worry.
“Like with the whole Spurs squad, Frank is getting to grips with how he sees it going forward, what work needs to be done. The fact Spurs are still in the market for another wide player may be an indication that Johnson has work to do to convince Frank that he has a long-term future.”
If the club keeps searching for new wide options, Johnson’s challenge will grow tougher in the coming months. Meanwhile, Spurs have linked themselves with a move for Ivan Toney, who stays happy at Al Ahli and refuses to seek a transfer this winter, showing how the club keeps reviewing its attacking setup.
The struggle for consistency and redemption
Brennan Johnson’s Tottenham story mixes growth with frustration. Under Ange Postecoglou, he shifted from Nottingham Forest’s counter-attacking setup to a possession-heavy system, where he refined his positioning and learned to adjust to tighter spaces.
When Thomas Frank arrived in the summer of 2025, he moved Johnson to the left flank, letting the forward exploit defensive gaps with late runs to the far post. Johnson finished the 2024–25 season as Tottenham’s top scorer with 18 goals, including the winning strike in the Europa League final, a moment that confirmed his potential.
However, inconsistency still hinders his progress. The Walesman’s form often mirrors Tottenham’s rhythm; when the team moves the ball quickly and stretches opponents, he looks confident and dangerous, but when play slows down, he loses involvement and impact. Criticism and online abuse have shaken his confidence and affected his focus. Tottenham demand a reliable wide player, and Frank’s demanding style leaves no room for uneven performances.
Still, Johnson’s finishing ability and intelligent movement show he can recover and claim a regular place. Tottenham’s coaches believe his adaptability will decide his long-term success. If he stays focused and determined, he can silence the doubts. Spurs even plan to recall Donley from Stoke City to strengthen their attack, which shows Frank closely monitors every forward option.
So, Johnson now controls his own future. His consistency and mindset will decide whether he turns periodic moments of brilliance into steady performances or lets Tottenham’s transfer plans push him aside. For now, Frank waits, hopeful but cautious.
