Connect with us

ARTICLES

Former Premier League explains why VAR did not award Tottenham a penalty vs Brentford

Published

on

Former Premier League referee explains why VAR did not award Tottenham Hotspur’s Harry Kane a penalty vs Brentford for Ben Mee challenge

Tottenham Hotspur’s Harry Kane was brought down by Ben Mee in Spurs’ Premier League derby against Brentford on Boxing Day at the Gtech Community Stadium.

Those in Tottenham colours were adamant that it was a penalty. David Coote did not initially award Kane a penalty, but fans would have thought that VAR would overturn.

But it didn’t. Mee’s challenge was clumsy inside the box and came at a time when the Lilywhites were trailing 1-0. A goal here would have given Tottenham approximately 40 minutes to hunt for the winner.

Ivan Toney of Brentford FC greets Harry Kane of Tottenham Hotspur after the Premier League match between Brentford FC and Tottenham Hotspur at Brentford Community Stadium on December 26, 2022 in Brentford, England. (Photo by Eddie Keogh/Getty Images)
Goalscorers: Ivan Toney of Brentford FC greets Harry Kane of Tottenham Hotspur. (Photo by Eddie Keogh/Getty Images)

Now, former Premier League referee Dermot Gallagher has explained why the Video Assistant Referee did not see it right to overturn the decision. He said (h/t Sky Sports’ Ref Watch):

“I thought both Mee and Kane were grabbing at each other. Kane has got a hold of Mee at the back as well so I think it’s one where if a penalty is going to be given, it has to be an on-field decision.”

“VAR aren’t going to overturn it. There needs to be enough doubt and it’s what we’ll see moving forward. VAR will only step in when it is clear and obvious.”

It does make sense to some extent if we view the incident in light of current PL rules. An on-field decision has to be a clear and obvious error for it to be overturned.

This would annoy fans for sure. If it’s a penalty, it should be a penalty. Of course, not a lot of us would have had an issue if roles were reversed and the Bees weren’t awarded a spot-kick for a similar challenge.

As it turned out, Ivan Toney scored two minutes later to make it 2-0. We scored two quick goals and had around 20 minutes to win the game, but couldn’t manage a third goal.

More Tottenham Hotspur News:

One can now only wonder how different things would have been had the 29-year-old been awarded a penalty kick in the 52nd minute and made it 1-1.

Spurs Transfer News

Piero Hincapie of Ecuador linked with a transfer to Tottenham Hotspur. Piero Hincapie of Ecuador linked with a transfer to Tottenham Hotspur.
Club5 hours ago

Tottenham looking to sign Piero Hincapie in a Pape Sarr-type deal

Tottenham Hotspur want to sign Bayer Leverkusen’s Piero Hincapie in a Pape Sarr-type deal Tottenham Hotspur are seemingly keen to...

Jude Soonsup-Bell of Chelsea FC controls the ball. (Photo by Warren Little/Getty Images ) Jude Soonsup-Bell of Chelsea FC controls the ball. (Photo by Warren Little/Getty Images )
Club5 hours ago

Tottenham Hotspur agree deal to sign young Chelsea striker

Tottenham Hotspur agree deal to sign young Chelsea striker Jude Soonsup-Bell Tottenham Hotspur have apparently agreed on a deal to...

Tottenham Hotspur 'really close' to sealing transfer for Sporting CP full-back and Spain international Pedro Porro. Tottenham Hotspur 'really close' to sealing transfer for Sporting CP full-back and Spain international Pedro Porro.
Club1 day ago

“Here we go!”- Fabrizio Romano confirms Pedro Porro’s move to Tottenham

Fabrizio Romano confirms Pedro Porro is set for Tottenham Hotspur transfer Fabrizio Romano has given the long-awaited ‘Here we go!’...

Djed Spence 'expected' to leave Tottenham Hotspur on loan ahead of January transfer window deadline day. Djed Spence 'expected' to leave Tottenham Hotspur on loan ahead of January transfer window deadline day.
Club2 days ago

Tottenham summer addition expected to make January loan exit on deadline day

Djed Spence ‘expected’ to leave Tottenham Hotspur on loan ahead of January transfer window deadline day Tottenham Hotspur star Djed...

Arsenal 'joined' by Tottenham Hotspur in pursuit of Montpellier striker Elye Wahi. Arsenal 'joined' by Tottenham Hotspur in pursuit of Montpellier striker Elye Wahi.
Club2 days ago

Transfer News: Arsenal battle Tottenham for Ligue 1 star Elye Wahi

Arsenal ‘joined’ by Tottenham Hotspur in pursuit of Montpellier striker Elye Wahi Tottenham Hotspur have ‘joined’ bitter rivals Arsenal in...

Pape Matar Sarr of Tottenham Hotspur battles for possession with Thomas Partey of Arsenal during the Premier League match between Tottenham Hotspur and Arsenal FC at Tottenham Hotspur Stadium on January 15, 2023 in London, England. (Photo by Clive Rose/Getty Images) Pape Matar Sarr of Tottenham Hotspur battles for possession with Thomas Partey of Arsenal during the Premier League match between Tottenham Hotspur and Arsenal FC at Tottenham Hotspur Stadium on January 15, 2023 in London, England. (Photo by Clive Rose/Getty Images)
ARTICLES2 days ago

Transfer News: Tottenham’s stance on Pape Matar Sarr’s future this season

Spurs Transfer News: Tottenham Hotspur don’t want to loan Espanyol target Pape Matar Sarr Tottenham Hotspur look set to keep...

Emi Buendia of Aston Villa and Bryan Gil of Tottenham Hotspur during a Premier League match. Emi Buendia of Aston Villa and Bryan Gil of Tottenham Hotspur during a Premier League match.
ARTICLES2 days ago

“Nothing has changed”- Tottenham coach gives update on Bryan Gil’s future amid Sevilla interest

Tottenham Hotspur coach Cristian Stellini gives update on Bryan Gil’s future amid Sevilla interest Three weeks ago, Tottenham Hotspur assistant...

Alastair Gold says Antonio Conte would like to sign Weston McKennie for Tottenham. Alastair Gold says Antonio Conte would like to sign Weston McKennie for Tottenham.
ARTICLES2 days ago

PL club ‘convinced’ they lead Arsenal and Tottenham in race for USA international

Leeds ‘convinced’ they will beat Tottenham Hotspur in race for Juventus star Weston McKennie Leeds United are ‘convinced’ they are...

Newcastle United tipped to sign Tottenham Hotspur duo Harry Kane and Son Heung-min. Newcastle United tipped to sign Tottenham Hotspur duo Harry Kane and Son Heung-min.
ARTICLES3 days ago

“Harry Kane and Son Heung-min in black and white”- PL rivals urged to move for Tottenham Hotspur’s star duo

Newcastle United tipped to sign Tottenham Hotspur duo Harry Kane and Son Heung-min Speaking on No Tippy Tappy Football, from William...

Pedro Porro could be an upgrade on Tottenham Hotspur's right-back options from the get-go. (Photo by PATRICIA DE MELO MOREIRA/AFP via Getty Images) Pedro Porro could be an upgrade on Tottenham Hotspur's right-back options from the get-go. (Photo by PATRICIA DE MELO MOREIRA/AFP via Getty Images)
ARTICLES3 days ago

“All parties confident”- Romano delivers Pedro Porro transfer update that will please Tottenham fans

Fabrizio Romano says Pedro Porro will sign contract until 2028 at Tottenham Hotspur Tottenham Hotspur seem closer than ever to...